What you bake
Best Pies to Ship for Christmas: 5 That Survive the Mail
A clear list of pies that survive shipping, with packing and cost math for each.
On this page
Christmas orders pile up fast, and a pie that arrives broken costs you a refund and a customer. The best pies to ship for Christmas are the ones you can bake ahead, wrap tight, and send without worry. This guide covers which fillings survive the trip, how to pack them, and how to price them so shipping does not eat your profit.
Which pies hold up in a box?
Look for a pie that is firm when cool and does not slump in the box. Apple, cherry, and pecan pies hold their shape because the filling is thick and stable. Sweet potato and pumpkin pies work when you bake them firm. Hand pies and fried pies are the safest of all because the filling is sealed inside a crust that acts like a container.
A sturdy crust matters as much as the filling. A flaky all butter crust can crack under pressure, so a slightly sturdier crust travels better. Blind baking the bottom crust helps it stay crisp instead of soggy. If the filling is loose, add a thickener and bake until the center no longer jiggles when you shake the pan.
Custard, cream, and meringue pies need constant cold and they weep in transit. The moisture ruins the crust and the filling separates into a puddle. Save those for local pickup or hand delivery. A pie that must stay refrigerated is a pie that should not go in the mail.
A 9 inch pie ships better than a deep dish. The filling has less room to shift and the crust has less weight to hold. If you sell deep dish, pack it with extra support and warn the customer to handle it gently when it arrives.
How to pack a pie for shipping
Bake it firm
Bake until the crust is deep gold and the filling is thick and set. A soft pie will slump in transit and arrive as a mess.
Cool it cold
Chill the pie overnight before packing. Cold filling holds its shape far better than warm, and the crust firms up.
Wrap it tight
Wrap the whole pie in plastic, then place it in a box with crumpled paper or bubble wrap on all six sides.
Ship it fast
Choose the fastest service you can afford. A pie that spends two extra days in a warehouse is a pie that arrives stale.
For extra safety, place the wrapped pie in a second box with a frozen gel pack. The air gap between the boxes acts like insulation. Do not let the pie touch the sides of the inner box. Fill every gap so it cannot slide during handling.
Tape the box well and add a fragile label. Include a small card that tells the customer to refrigerate on arrival and eat within two days. Good instructions prevent a refund when the crust is not perfect or the shape has shifted slightly.
What shipping and overhead really cost
Postage is only part of the cost. You also pay for the box, the wrap, and the tool you use to take orders and get paid. Brevl costs $20 a month with no commission, so that is a fixed overhead you can plan around. If you use a site that takes a cut of every sale, that percentage adds up fast during the Christmas rush.
Ship 12 pies in December. Brevl costs $20 for the month, so overhead is about $1.67 per pie. Charge $25 per pie, inside the $18 to $32 range our cherry pie guide lists. If ingredients cost $7 and your time is $12, your margin is $4.33 per pie. Add the box, label, and gas, and you see why guessing on price hurts. Track every pie so you know your true margin before you bake the next batch.
Charge shipping as a separate line so the customer sees the real cost. A flat rate is easier to manage, but weigh a few boxes first. If you undercharge postage, the difference comes out of your margin. You can check current rates and rules in our best carrier guide.
A site that takes 10 percent of a $25 pie keeps $2.50. On 12 pies that is $30, more than the $20 flat fee for the month. During Christmas volume, a flat fee usually wins. Run the numbers before you list so you keep more of each sale.
Mistakes that cost you money
Sending a pie warm is the fastest way to lose money. The filling sweats, the crust softens, and mold can start before the box is even opened. Another costly mistake is using a thin box with no cushion. A pie that arrives as crumbs is a full refund plus the postage you already spent, and you cannot resell it.
Do not skip tracking. If a package goes missing, you need proof it arrived or did not. Also, check the weather before you ship. A pie stuck in a hot warehouse for three days will not taste like Christmas. You can read more about craft basics on our craft hub.
Ship early in the week so the pie does not sit in a warehouse over the weekend. Monday and Tuesday are the safest days. Tell the customer the pie is best eaten within two days of arrival. A clear message prevents a bad review and a refund request.
Before you sell a single pie, ship one to a friend across the country. See how it survives the trip. If the crust is soggy or the box is crushed, change your packing before a customer finds the problem for you. A test run costs you one pie and saves your Christmas season.
Decide your refund policy before December. If a pie arrives broken, do you reship or refund? Put the policy in your shop so the customer knows what to expect. A clear rule protects your margin and your reputation when something goes wrong. It also saves you from arguing in a message thread on Christmas Eve.
In summer, a gel pack is not enough. Use insulation and ship overnight if you can. In winter, protect the pie from freezing during transit. Extreme cold can crack a crust just as easily as heat can spoil a filling.
Try the free bake pricing calculator
Free, no signup.
- Best carrier for shipping baked goods
- Best baked goods for shipping
- How much do people charge for pies
Common questions
Can I ship a pumpkin pie for Christmas?
Yes, if you bake it firm and chill it before packing. Pumpkin filling is thick, so it holds shape better than custard. Wrap it well and ship fast. Tell the customer to refrigerate it when it arrives and eat it within two days for the best taste and texture.
What is the cheapest way to pack a pie?
Use a sturdy cardboard box that fits the pie with about two inches of space on every side. Fill the gaps with crumpled paper or cheap bubble wrap. You do not need fancy packaging. You need cushion and a tight seal so the pie cannot move inside the box.
Should I charge extra for shipping?
Yes, charge shipping as its own line so the customer sees the real cost. Weigh a few packed boxes to set a fair flat rate. If you hide postage in the pie price, you may sell at a loss during the busy season and not notice until January.
How do I keep the crust from getting soggy?
Blind bake the bottom crust before you add the filling. Let the pie cool completely, then chill it overnight. Cold filling and a firm crust pack better. A warm pie sweats in the box, and that moisture is what turns the crust soft.
Can I use Brevl to track my Christmas pie orders?
Brevl lets you take orders and get paid through your own Stripe or Square account, plus Venmo, Cash App, Zelle, and cash. It costs $20 a month with no commission. You can see every order on your phone, which helps during the December rush.
General information, not legal or tax advice.