Selling and marketing
Best Price for Crave Dog Treats: Cost per Ounce (2026)
A per ounce method for comparing Crave bags, so you know which pack is actually cheapest.
On this page
What to remember
- Cost per ounce is the only number that compares two bags fairly.
- Add shipping and any membership fee before you call one bag cheaper.
- Check the price in the cart, not on the signup banner.
- A sale on a small bag often loses to a big bag at full price.
- Compare the bag to what a homemade batch costs you, labor included.
Bag prices move around, and the sticker on the shelf tells you very little. Finding the best price for crave dog treats takes one extra step: turn every option into a cost per ounce, then compare like for like. The math takes about two minutes on your phone.
Turn every bag into a cost per ounce
Pick the three or four bags you can actually buy this week, online or in the store. Write down the price and the net weight in ounces, which is printed on the front of the bag. Divide price by ounces and you have a number you can rank. Do the same for every size.
Do this on paper or in your phone notes, not in your head. Prices change, and you will want the old number to compare against. A simple list of bag, ounces, price, and cost per ounce is enough.
Write down the net weight
Net weight is the ounces of treats, not the weight of the bag. It is on the front panel.
Divide the price by the ounces
That gives you dollars per ounce. A bag that costs twice as much but holds three times the treats is the cheaper one.
Add shipping per bag
If shipping is one flat fee, divide it across the bags in the order before you compare.
Add any membership fee
A club membership only pays off if you buy enough there in a year to cover it.
Check the price in the cart
Autoship and coupon prices can change between the shelf and the checkout page.
Try the free bake pricing calculator
Free, no signup.
Where the price actually moves
Pack size is the biggest lever. The same line often comes in a small bag and a large bag, and the large bag usually wins on cost per ounce. That is not a rule you can trust without checking, because the gap between sizes changes. Run the division on both.
Shipping is the second lever. A cheaper bag with a shipping fee can lose to a slightly higher bag that ships free. If you buy more than one bag at a time, spread the shipping across the whole order before you compare it to a single bag elsewhere.
Autoship is the third lever. It is worth pricing, but read the delivery schedule as carefully as the discount. A bag every two weeks can cost more over a year than a bigger bag every six weeks, even when the per bag price looks lower.
Buying more than one bag at a time is worth pricing too. A two bag order can spread a flat shipping fee thin, and some stores price a multipack below the single bag. Do the division on the multipack total, not on the single bag price.
What to check before you commit
Read the net weight, not the treat count. A bag that says 40 treats tells you nothing about ounces, and treat size varies between products. Ounces are the only number you can compare across brands and sizes.
Check the return policy before you buy a size you have never tried. A store that takes back an open bag is worth more than a few cents off, because a food your dog will not eat is money gone. Keep the receipt until the bag is open.
When a homemade batch beats the bag
If you already bake for sale, you have a third option: make the treats yourself and price them like any other product. That only works if you count ingredients, your time, and overhead. A batch that ignores your labor is not cheaper, it is just unpaid. The same cost method in how to price for baked goods applies here.
For example, say a batch of 40 small treats uses $6 of ingredients and $2 of packaging. Your oven runs for an hour, and you count your time at $18 an hour for two hours, which is $36. Your shop costs $20 a month, and you make four batches a month, so $5 of that lands on this batch. Total cost is $49, or about $1.23 a treat. Price them at $2 each and the batch brings in $80, leaving $31, a margin of about 39 percent.
Now compare that $2 a treat to the cost per treat of the bag you priced earlier. If the bag comes out lower, buying is the better deal for you, and there is no shame in that. If your batch wins, you have a product you can sell.
Mistakes that cost you money
The first mistake is comparing two bags by sticker price. The second is leaving shipping and membership fees out of the comparison. The third is buying a size your dog has never tried, then finding out it does not agree with him. Each one costs more than the few cents you were chasing.
One more habit worth building: write the cost per ounce on the bag with a marker. Next time you shop, you compare against your own note instead of starting over. For more on running the money side of a home food business, see tips for selling baked goods from home.
If you sell your own treats, set the price from cost and margin, not from what the bag at the store costs. How to price baked goods for profit walks through the same math with a margin target.
Common questions
Is the biggest bag always the best price for crave dog treats?
No. A bigger bag usually lowers the cost per ounce, but not always, and the gap between sizes changes. Run the division on each size you can buy. Then check that the bag will stay fresh long enough for your dog to finish it.
Does autoship give the lowest price?
Sometimes, but check the delivery schedule as well as the price. A small discount on a frequent delivery can cost more over a year than a larger bag bought less often. Compare the yearly total, not the per bag number on the signup page.
How do I compare a bag to homemade treats?
Cost your batch the same way you cost any baked good: ingredients, packaging, your time, and a share of your monthly overhead. Divide by the number of treats. Then compare that number to the cost per treat of the bag.
What if my dog will not eat the big bag?
Buy the smallest size first, even though it costs more per ounce. A bag your dog refuses is a total loss, and the return policy may not cover opened food. Keep the receipt until you know he likes it.
Should I count my own time when I make treats?
Yes, if you sell them. A batch priced without your time looks cheap and pays you nothing. Count the hours you actually spend, including shopping, baking, cooling, and packing, then add a margin on top of the full cost.
General information about pricing, not legal or tax advice. Check your own state rules before you sell food from home.